OVERLOOKING a disused power station, with not a coffee shop or restaurant in
sight, Balmain's White Bay will become the entry point for hundreds of thousands
of international tourists visiting Sydney.
For residents of the inner west, the decision means a peninsula that already
carries heavy traffic will face even more congestion each time a cruise ship
comes to port.
For a city trying to revamp its tourist appeal, the journey from the terminal
across Anzac Bridge to the city's main attractions would take the gloss off the
visit.
"White Bay is a sub-optimal location," said Ann Sherry, the head of Carnival
Australia, which handles the largest number of cruise ships visiting Sydney.
The Government announced the little-noticed decision just before Christmas.
The Minister for Ports, Joe Tripodi, and the Planning Minister, Kristina
Keneally, are behind the move to White Bay, which will create political
difficulties for the local member, Verity Firth, a rising star in the
Government, who holds the education portfolio. She holds the seat of Balmain by
a margin of only 3.75 per cent and any backlash could let the seat fall to the
Greens.
"As far as we are concerned the Government has not thought through the idea
at all," said the Leichhardt Mayor, Jamie Parker.
"It is a high-density residential area and traffic in and out of White Bay is
already a nightmare."
Each cruise ship arrival would involve 600-1000 traffic movements, and at
least 30 truck movements, which would be repeated for each departure.
Port facilities for visiting cruise ships were included in the initial
Barangaroo redevelopment at East Darling Harbour but they have since been
dropped.
The Government says cruise ships need an onshore "exclusion zone" for
immigration and customs, which will be available only at White Bay, even though
internationally such facilities are incorporated in port-side shopping malls.
The Government has said the White Bay terminal will be temporary, but the
existing Darling Harbour facility was also supposed to be temporary and it has
been in use for a decade.
When it is operational, the White Bay terminal will handle more than 75
vessels a year.
Cruise ship demand is well ahead of port capacity but the Government has yet
to clarify its longer-term thinking for the industry, particularly whether White
Bay will be a permanent solution.
"For a State Government so keen on big announcements, they sure kept this one
under wraps," the Opposition ports spokesman, Andrew Stoner, said.
"Residents and the local council were not even told about the plans. If Joe
Tripodi and Verity Firth want a cruise ship terminal built in Balmain they
should have at least have had the guts to consult with the local community."